Sugar and Spice and everything nice… Round 12:
The third and final, consecutive Christmas #1 for the Spice Girls was Goodbye in 1998. Mel B. and Victoria are heavily pregnant. Melanie C. is heavily anorexic and to be quite frank, really frightening to watch. Contrary to popular interpretation, mostly due to the timing of it’s release, the song is not, in fact, about Geri’s departure from the group. Furthermore, Halliwell penned most of the lyrics, but after she left, her name was taken out of the writing credits. Of the three singles released without Halliwell, this is the only one that she sang during the Return of the Spice Girls tour. This is one of the most beautifully written Spice Girls songs, both lyrically and melodically.